@worrydream “bookshelf” is completely the wrong mental model. A “list of links” is like a list of postal addresses of places (hence web “address”) as a physical analogy, or the contents of their authors brains as a human analogy. Complaining about their contents changing/disappearing is as complaining that space/time/humans are “a disaster” (which admittedly may broadly be true).
“your bookshelf” is whatever personal archives you make of your favourite things (analogies: photos, notes, physical books), and therefore the solution is better personal archival tools. I’ve made a start — my website automatically takes an archive of every page I link to and stores it as HTML+HTTP headers in the filesystem, which has proven to be a quite robust format.
Of course if you actually have a practical idea about how to improve on the infrastructure of the web, speak up and/or build it :)
Edit: reflecting on this, “completely the wrong mental model” is incorrect, and better expressed as “a mental model which is inconsistent with reality”. There are no “wrong” mental models, only a variety of co-existing metaphors with varying levels and areas of consistency with reality.
Bret Victor
Ben Werdmüller
Erin McKean
Smári McCarthy
Jessica
Hrafn Þorvaldsson
Bastian Allgeier
Aral Balkan
Kevin Marks
Sophie Dennis
Aitor García Rey
Benjamin Atkin
Stuart Langridge